Hardship withdrawals are often treated as a sign that someone failed to save or plan well, but financial emergencies are usually more complicated than that. A car repair, medical bill, eviction notice, or other unexpected expense can leave people with few accessible options outside their retirement account. Vanguard reported that approximately six percent of retirement plan participants took a hardship withdrawal in 2025, with a median withdrawal of about $1,900 and foreclosure or eviction prevention and medical bills among the most common reasons.
In her recent Kiplinger article, Sophie Benander challenges the idea that hardship withdrawals are primarily a discipline problem. She writes, “The early withdrawal isn’t the problem. It’s a symptom,” and explains that people may be reaching for “the last cushion they have, because every other one is already gone.” Her perspective encourages readers to look at the financial fragility behind the withdrawal rather than focusing only on the decision to take money from a 401(k).
Sophie also encourages readers to consider what could create more financial flexibility before the next emergency. She suggests looking beyond a growing retirement balance and asking how long someone could manage using money they can access without touching retirement savings, while recognizing that a small, separate emergency fund may help create a buffer over time.
“The account is never the whole picture. The life around it is.”
Interested in learning more? Read the full article on Kiplinger here.
This website uses cookies. By accepting the use of cookies, this message will close and you will receive the optimal website experience. For more information on our cookie policy, please visit our Privacy Policy.
